New York-Style Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich
The breakfast sandwich that conquered the Big Apple. No true New Yorker starts their day without a delicious and gooey B.E.C (which is short for Bacon Egg and Cheese)!
I was never an egg sandwich lover.
In fact, with the exception of frittatas and omelettes, I’m not much of an egg person, period. For example, I will run for the hills at the sight of an egg salad.??? Sorry, egg lovers, but the truth is I didn’t come into this world with the egg gene.
So, it took me a long time to have my first Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich. I am even a little embarrassed to admit, but it was only this year. Yep, after living in NYC for the past 6 years, I finally tried my first BEC. And it was awesome!
Okay, maybe not as awesome at first, since it was at a Dunkin’ Donuts.
Tim and I were on a road trip somewhere and I was starving. At the sight of the first food court/gas station thingy, I made him stop and we went to get some food. As I was looking through the menu, I though: well, I hate egg sandwiches, but at least this so called Bacon Egg and Cheese will keep me full for the rest of the ride. So I got one. And I ate it all! “This is promising!”, I remember thinking as I chomped down my breakfast, feeling a little less cranky.
Since I couldn’t tell if the sandwich pleased me because it was really good or because I was starving and would have been happy with anything edible, I decided to have it again a few weeks later, at a New York City deli. It was even better – obviously! – and I was forever hooked!
Question of the day: do you know the difference between a Bacon Egg and Cheese and a New York-Style Bacon Egg and Cheese?
And the answer is: in New York we like it inside a bagel. Preferably an everything bagel! If you answered right, congratulations! ? Either you are a real New Yorker or a serious foodie.
Your prize? What do you mean where’s your prize? Your prize is the privilege of being my cyber friend. You’re welcome! ?
For whatever reason, it’s near impossible to find a good bacon egg and cheese sandwich outside of New York, so people usually settle for not so great imitations, like an Egg McMuffin.
So, if you’re not a New Yorker with a deli in walking distance, all that’s left to do is sit and cry.
Until now!
Seriously, this recipe makes a B.E.C that is as good or better than the ones you’ll find in Manhattan. No need to pay the outrageous rents in the Big Apple. You can make this delicious breakfast sandwich anywhere in the world!
And even if you’re a New Yorker that can walk to a deli in less than 30 seconds, give this a try! Not only will you save money, but you will feel proud that you made a homemade Bacon Egg and Cheese.
For the sake of being authentic, I used my least favorite cheese: American cheese. Surprisingly enough, it works like a charm. The cheese melts beautifully and it’s almost like cheese and egg become one single being, a very awesome being!
This is one sandwich that is not necessarily improved by better cheese, so save the gouda for another culinary creation.
It is all about the simple ingredients, designed to satisfy practical needs rather than voluptuary desires, that can be put together quickly, because New Yorkers don’t have time to lose. Hence why they usually buy it from a bodega or a street cart outside their offices.
But believe me, the joy you’ll feel by whipping up this gloriously simple and satisfying sandwich at home beats waiting on a crowded bodega any time.
Plus, you get to enjoy this ooey-gooey goodness sitting on your couch (or table) instead of on a dirty NY subway car. (Unless you wanna make it to go. Because you totally can!)
P.S. A shout out to my friend Kevin from Kevin is Cooking, because he gifted me that beautiful wood board that you can see in these pictures! :) Thank you again, Kevin, for this wonderful gift. You are the best! ❤️
New York-Style Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich
New York-Style Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich Author: Olivia's Cuisine
Ingredients
- 1 bagel (plain, whole wheat or everything)
- 3 tablespoons butter, divided
- 2 slices of bacon, cooked
- 2 eggs
- 2 slices of American cheese
- Salt and freshly ground pepper to taste
Instructions
Notes
Adapted from Mad Hungry by Lucinda Scala Quinn.
22 Comments on “New York-Style Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich”
Oh how I love this! So very similar to my favorite breakfast at a local Canadian coffee shop: BELT Bagel
I love breakfast bagels!
I’m sorry that you don’t like eggs, I didn’t for a very long time. There was something about the smell and texture that made me feel sick.
This looks awesome though!
Bacon egg and cheese is the best combination ever! And I love the wooden board I need to get something like that for my food photography :)
Breakfast bagels are fun. I look forward to Friday’s when we do the breakfast bagels at work. Your recipe is awesome. Pinning it
Everything bagels are delish ~ wish we could get quality bagels in Texas :(.
Bagel sandwiches for breakfast is the best thing. Love how beautiful and delicious they are.
Me too..can’t eat eggs in sandwiches, I am okay with omelette though..my husband is extreme, he just won’t touch anything with egg in it! I love the bagels here and the cheese of course!
Never cook the yolk all the way! Leave it slightly runny (over medium). You won’t be sorry :)
I don’t know how I missed this one! Thanks for making me hungry even though I have a cold and for the shout out my dear. Cheers!
This looks fantastic!!! I love bagel sandwiches, and making a breakfast sandwich with them ooohh YUM!!! I’ll be trying this out soon. It looks heavenly!
Yumm. Doing this now because I just made fresh bagels 🥯
Wtf nobody likes a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel u only been living there for like 6.5 years u not from New York I’m from New York born and raised but I’m not trynna be rude it’s just I’m a native and u trynna disrespect bacon eggs and cheese we like it from the
ocks on a roll or a hero mama understand good.
Hi Oswald,
You can definitely make this on a roll! :) All my years living in Manhattan, I’ve always had it on a bagel, but either way works!
No no no, a “New York style” baconegg&cheese is served on a kaiser roll.
You can definitely make it on a roll! I prefer on a bagel. 😊
What’re you talkin about lady?! You want a real ‘New York BEC’, you get it with mayo and hot sauce, on a roll. I’ve never seen a born and raised New Yorker have it on a bagel. Sac-relig
You can make it however you’d like! This is the way I’ve always had it at delis in Manhattan for the 10 years I’ve lived here.
I actually used cracked sourdough bread and shredded cheese! It tasted very good!!!
Sounds delicious with sourdough!
I grew up in central NY, have had this sandwich on a bagel, crumpet, and biscuit. Sorry, but on a bagel everything squirts out and you end up eating soggy bagel at the end. After spending years down south, biscuit is the way to go!
Never tried it in a biscuit! Will do it ASAP. Sounds delicious!
In the recipe it says to layer the egg wirh bacon and cheese then flip and cook until cheese melts. In the picture your bacon is on top of the eggs. Do I add the bacon while eggs are still cooking or just add bacon on top after eggs are done?